Understanding the New Penalty Rates Legislation and Its Impact

September 10, 2025 · IR & Employee Matters

The Australian Government has enacted the Penalty Rates Legislation, fulfilling Labor’s pre-election commitment to safeguard penalty and overtime rates in modern awards. This legislative reform is a direct response to recent applications to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) by some employers seeking to increase base rates in retail, banking, and clerical awards while effectively absorbing existing penalty and overtime entitlements.

Key Provisions of the Legislation

The Penalty Rates Legislation introduces section 135A into the Fair Work Act, establishing clear boundaries for the FWC when making, varying, or revoking modern awards. Under this section, the FWC must ensure that:

  • Penalty or overtime rates are not reduced.
  • Modern awards do not include terms substituting these rates in a way that reduces an employee’s overall remuneration.

These measures prevent reductions in existing penalty and overtime rates and prohibit arrangements such as “rolled-up” base hourly rates that could leave employees financially worse off.

Implications for Employers

The primary aim of the legislation is to protect employee entitlements and prevent attempts to absorb penalty and overtime rates into higher base pay. Importantly, the legislation does not introduce new compliance obligations beyond those already imposed under the Fair Work Act and modern awards. For most employers, day-to-day operations and payroll practices will not change immediately.

However, some questions remain regarding annualised wage arrangements and other substitution clauses within modern awards. While the legislation is not retrospective, it may affect these provisions if the FWC reviews an award in the future. Existing annualised wage arrangements and contractual set-off clauses remain valid unless specifically varied or revoked.

It is also crucial to note that the legislation does not affect individual flexibility agreements or enterprise bargaining arrangements under the Fair Work Act.

What Employers Should Do Now

While these changes do not impose immediate new obligations, they serve as a timely reminder for employers to:

  • Review award compliance regularly, ensuring employee classifications and entitlements are accurate.
  • Interpret awards correctly, particularly in relation to penalty and overtime rates.
  • Ensure payroll systems are configured to meet modern award requirements and avoid inadvertent breaches.

By proactively maintaining compliance and monitoring changes, employers can ensure they continue to meet their obligations while safeguarding employee rights under modern awards.

For assistance, contact CCF NSW on 9009 4000.