A civil contractor has been fined $225,000 after a man riding an electric bicycle collided with a road plate in the Sydney suburb of Eastwood and suffered fatal injuries.
The road plate was feathered in the direction of travel on the road (north to south) but the cyclist, Xi Zeng, hit a side perpendicular to the direction of traffic.
This caused him to come off his bike and suffer brain injuries, he later died in hospital.
There were two road plates covering a trench in this case and, initially, they were unsecured and not feathered in any direction.
The morning prior to the fatal incident, a council employee directed the civil contractor involved to make the site safe.
The contractor secured the plates to the road and feathered them in the direction of travel.
That evening, Mr Zeng hit the road plate and sustained the fatal injuries.
In his finding, NSW Industrial Court Justice Lloyd Babb, said, “There was a plethora of guidance material available to the offender at the time of the incident,” before listing half a dozen sources including three SafeWork NSW codes of practice.
Justice Babb noted:
In the present case, the failure of the offender to feather all edges of the road plates to prevent road users from impacting with the hard steel edge of the road plates or from swerving or manoeuvring to avoid such impact is a fundamental consideration. Equally fundamental, is the fact that the feathering of all edges of road plates was a straightforward and obvious step to take.
Importantly, that was not the only relevant failure on the part of the offender. There was no risk assessment regarding the use and installation of the road plates undertaken by the offender. There was no appropriate signage on the road warning road users of hazards and there was no temporary lighting installed to illuminate the hazard. Further, the traffic cones and barriers at the site should have been closer to the gutter or removed altogether to minimise funnelling the road users’ path of travel closer to the middle of the road and thereby closer to the hazard of the unfeathered edges of the steel road plates.
All of those failures came against a background of publications which warned of the dangers of road plates generally, and the need for them to be recessed into the road surface so they are flush with the road or be feathered by making bituminous ramps along all exposed edges. Moreover, the publications indicated the need for adequate signposting and lighting to warn of the hazard and the need for traffic devices not to direct road users into an undesirable path.
Justice Babb said a $300,000 fine is appropriate but reduced it in this case to $225,000 because the contractor pleaded guilty.
For help or further information, please contact CCF NSW on (02) 9009 4000 or ccfnsw@ccfnsw.com